Yu.V. Patiutko, D.V. Podluzhnyi, A.G. Kotelnikov, I.V. Sagaidak
Moscow,The N.N. Blokhin Institute of Clinical Oncology of Russian Oncological Center of RAMS
Liver and Pancreas Surgery Ward
The cryogenic method belongs to the challenging methods in therapy; it is increasingly used in medical practice in general, and in oncology in particular. In the recent years, the cryogenic method has been applied in oncourology, oncogynecology, and hepatology. At present, the cryosurgery is gradually moving forward to occupy its deserved position in treatment of pancreas tumors as well. However, there are scarcely any publications in the foreign and local literature on the subject of treatment of pancreas malignant tumors. Thus, in the available literature S.A. Shalimov, L.V. Keisevich, and A.A. Litvinenko (Ukraine, 1998) describe the method and results of treatment of 89 pancreas malignant tumor cases. The survival rate was as follows: 1 year - 29%, 3 years - 10%. At that, the authors collected all histological variants of tumors and did not conduct a remote survival analysis separately by each nosological form. Besides, the article describes the process of cryodestruction of the head of a pancreas as an independent treatment method without further pancreatoduodenectomy. In doing so, the authors do not exemplify the structure and number of postoperative complications, although, based on our experimental data, the risk of damage of duodenum wall with further development of necrosis and perforation is high enough. In general, the hollow organs located close to the point of cryoapplication must be handled with extreme care. Once we had to perform a distal resection of stomach for the avoidance of its damage in the process of cryodestruction of a pancreas body tumor in head transition.
G. Prokhorov with co-authors (Saint-Petersburg, 2005) exemplify the experience of cryosurgical treatment of 4 patients locally-spread pancreas tumors in the course of combined therapy. The maximum survival of these patients was 26 months. The median was 12.1 months.
The study of cryodestruction mechanisms, selection of the optimum exposure conditions for achievement of maximum destructive effect in tissues is the subject and the task of cryosurgery. The extent and volume of damage depend not only on the preset temperature and time parameters, but also on the type of the tissue exposed, on its resistance to low temperatures and adaptability (Lozina-Lozinskaya, 1972). In fact, the process of freezing of live biological structures, with water as their main component, consists in its transition from one aggregation state to other, but is far from being similar to purely physical process of crystallization. It is many orders more complicated and represents a complex of physical-chemical and biochemical changes (J. Coe, S. Rockoff, A. Omaya, 1965, J. Cooper, 1965, P. Mazur, 1970). The investigations conducted by many authors allow conclusions that quick freezing is more detrimental for cells that slow freezing. Besides, it is notorious, that quickly frozen cells containing intracellular ice, are more likely damaged at the stage of slow thawing than at the stage of freezing. The matter of cell survival following low-temperature application is of significance, especially in oncology. The low-temperature resistance of cells and their survival depend on the structural and functional features of organs and tissues, and are defined by the critical temperature. The range of critical temperatures for survival of various cell elements and tissues is from minus 5°C to minus 50°C (P. Mazur, 1970).
Clinical data
At the N.N. Blokhin Institute of Clinical Oncology of Russian Oncology Center of RAMS, cryosurgical treatment of pancreas tumors was conducted in 54 patients. At that, the following cryoapplication variants were used:
- Cryogenic treatment of tumors as an independent method. It was used for non-resectable pancreas tumors.
- Cryoapplication in combination with radical operation.
- Cryosurgery in combination with radiation therapy. The cryodestruction was supplemented by remote radiotherapy with fractionated dosage, or by remote gamma-therapy.
- Cryosurgery in combination with chemotherapy. The cryodestruction was supplemented by the standard schemes of polychemotherapy.
- Cryodestruction of the bed of excised tumor. It was performed in the case of non-radical or conventionally radical operation for mitigation of the risk of a local recurrence.
- Cryoapplication before organ mobilization. It was performed for exclusion of dissemination at mechanical destruction of a tumor in the process of its mobilization. Thereafter, a radical operation was performed.
Cryoapplication in case of pancreas body and pancreas tail cancer
The cryosurgical treatment of distal tumors of pancreas was performed in 51 patients. Of these: 26 (50.95) were men, and 25 (49.1%) were women. The average age was 58±9.1, the minimum age was 29, and the maximum age was 71 years.
In 44 patients, pancreas tumors were not resectable: a tumor was deemed locally spread (appreciable retroperitoneal invasion, invasion of upper mesenteric vessels - in 18 patients, of celiac trunk and its branches - in 9 patients, metastatic affection of the lymph nodes of regional lymph channel - in 3 patients, metastases to lymph nodes of mesentery root - in 5 patients), besides, liver metastases were revealed in 12 patients, abdominal metastases - in 2 patients, blastematic ascites - in 4 patients. 9 patients were in the IIA stage, 8 -patients - in the III stage, and 26 patients were in the IV stage of the tumor process.
Localization of the tumor process in the projection of pancreas body was observed in 14 (31.8%) patients, of pancreas body-tail - in 16 (36.4%) patients, of pancreas body-head - in 13 (29.5%) patients, and the total affection - in 1 (2.3%) patient. The convincing morphological verification at the preoperative stage was obtained in 45.6% of patients, doubtful - in 13.6% of patients, a tumor process was not verified in 9% of patient, and no verification was performed in 31.8% of patients. Pancreas duct adenocarcinoma was in 42 patients, pancreas cystadenocarcinoma was in 1 patient, and endocrinocellular cancer - in 1 patient.
The method of cryodestruction consisted in the following. Following laparotomy and decision on inoperability of the pancreas tumor, the tumor dimensions were determined (length and width), as well as the necessary dimensions of the tumor tissue freezing zone. The tumor depth was determined in the preoperative period by X-ray computer tomography. Following determination of dimensions and geometry of the intended cryodestruction zone, the ratio of cryoapplication cycles was determined, as well as location of the tumor with respect to the hollow organs, and the centers of application of cryoinstrument were determined. After it, the parameters of temperature and time conditions were selected, as well as the necessary dimensions of cryoapplicator. “Cryoelectronics-4(2)” apparatus was used for tumor freezing. The freezing was performed by direct contact method by way of placing cryoapplicator on the front tumor surface. Its temperature was set in the range from minus 170oC to minus 190oC, the time of a single exposure was from 10 to 25 minutes, and the diameter of cryoapplicator was from 20 to 50 mm. The last two parameters were chosen depending on the volume of tumor. We were the first to use a perforation applicator in the clinical practice. Its application was necessary if there was no confidence in complete destruction of tissue in the depth of neoplasm in the cases of large tumor dimensions. In a number of cases, cryoapplication was performed from two or three points. In some cases, cryoapplication was performed in two stages, with complete thawing and repeated cryodestruction in the same place. Cryodestruction was performed within the limits of sound tissues. The thawing was always spontaneous.
The study of activity of a-amylase of serum and transudate from abdominal cavity after cryodestruction revealed the following. During the first day following cryodestruction, the increase in activity of a-amylase of serum and transudate from abdominal cavity was 2.5 times and 2.1 times, respectively, as compared with the initial normal level. By the 5-th day after operation, the activity of a-amylase was brought to normal.
Of 44 patients that were subject to cryosurgical treatment for pancreas tumor, 3 patients died. Thus, the lethality rate was 6.8%. The reasons for lethality were as follows: acute hepatic insufficiency on the 7-th day after operation, acute cardiovascular insufficiency on the 2-nd day after operation, acute gastric ulcer bleeding on the 15-th day after operation. In pathologicoanatomic study of the data, pancreas inflammation was not observed; necrotized masses were observed in the tumor zone. However, the intact tumor tissue was observed around large blood vessels.
Taking into account more aggressive nature of duct adenocarcinoma as compared with cystadenocarcinoma and endocrinocellular cancer, we conducted a separate analysis of remote survival of duct adenocarcinoma cases.
The total survival in the group of patients with non-resectable distal-zone cancer of pancreas (only the cases with pancreas duct adenocarcinoma, excluding endocrinocellular cancer and cystadenocarcinoma) was 1 year - 11.8±5.1%, 2 years - 6.8±4.5%. Three-year’ survival was not observed. The median was 6 months.
The tumor recurrences or prolonged tumor growth are common after cryodestruction of pancreas tumor. The general idea is that the basis for tumor recurrences lies in restrictions of methodological nature connected with impossibility of achievement of the necessary temperature conditions in the immediate vicinity of large blood vessels and bowels, where vital tumor cells may survive as a consequence. In connection with it, the necessity arises in enhancing the destructive action of low temperatures on the tumor cells by way of combination of cryodestruction of pancreas tums with other treatment methods.
23 patients were subject to cryosurgical treatment only, 19 patients were subject to combined treatment (out of these: cryosurgery + radiation therapy - 10 patients, cryosurgery + chemotherapy - 9 patients).
The remote survival among the patients subject to cryodestruction alone of distal-zone cancer of pancreas was as follows: 1 year - 5.17 ± 3.35%. Two-year’ survival was not observed. The median was 5.8 months.
In the combined cryoradiation treatment, cryodestruction was supplemented by remote radiotherapy with 18-25MeV (18-25 МэВ) braking high-energy radiation performed by longitudinal method with prolonged course in the mode of dose superfractionation (ROD 2 g, SOD > 60 g), or by remote gamma-therapy in the similar doses. Radiation therapy was performed on the 10-12-th days following pancreas tumor cryodestruction, and if it was supported well, - without interruption. 3 more patients were not subject to complete course of radiotherapy , - the treatment was suspended at SOD < 40 g in consequence of side reactions in the form of general radiation reaction and radiation gastroenteritis developed in the process of treatment. The remote survival of the patients subject to cryosurgical treatment with subsequent radiation therapy was as follows: 1 year - 0%. The median was 6.7 months.
He remote survival of the patients subject to cryosurgical treatment with subsequent chemotherapy was as follows: 1 year - 25.0±14.4%, 2 years -25.±14.4% (survival of one patient in this group was 25 months). Three-year’ survival was not observed. The median was 9 months. The clinical observation of this patient is given below:
Patient C, 68 years old, was in the Liver and Pancreas Surgery Ward of Russian Oncological Center of RAMS from 21.12.04 to 12.01.05 with the following diagnosis:
Pancreas body cancer, T4NjM/, IVB stage
Since autumn of 2003, she had suffered from pain in epigastric zone. After the investigation in the policlinic, the pancreas body cancer was diagnosed (cytology No. 04/0568: adenocarcinoma). She was hospitalized to Liver and Pancreas Surgery Ward of Russian Oncological Center of RAMS. In the course of ultrasound investigation (USI, CT) and angiography, a pancreas body tumor was revealed with injury of celiac trunk and splenetic vessels. No other manifestation of the disease was revealed.
The patient was operated on 28.04.04. The following was established: 4×5 cm tumor of pancreas body with III hepatic lobe metastasis up to 2 cm. Taking dissemination of the tumor process into consideration, the decision was made to abstain from radical operation. Cryodestruction of pancreas tumor and atypic resection of hepatic lobe were performed. In histological examination, moderately differentiated liver metastasis of adenocarcinoma was diagnosed. The postoperation period was without complications. 6 courses of chemotherapy were conducted according to the following scheme: Gemzar - 1 g/m on the 1-st and 8-th days with 2 weeks’ interval.
In the control investigation in December 2004 (Ultrasonic study, MRT of abdominal cavity, and X-ray investigation of pectoral organs), no recurrences or metastases were revealed. However, the growth of tumor marker CA 19-9 from 45 ME/ml to 62 ME/ml was observed in October 2004. With regard to it, we decided to proceed with PCT according to the following scheme: Eloxatin 150 mg i/v with drop bottle on the 1 day, Gemzar 1.5 g i/v with drop bottle on the 1-st and 8-th days. The survival of the patient was 25 months after operation.
This case is of interest, because the originally disseminated patient with the exact morphological verification of the diagnosis has lived such a long time after cryodestruction. Its relation to chemotherapy only is problematic as other patients were subject to PCT with the use of the same medications without cryodestruction with much worse results.
The pancreas tumor cryodestruction was accompanied by a pronounced symptomatic effect: full release from pain - in 54.6% of patients, decrease of pain - in 38.6% of patients. No clinical effect of cryodestruction was observed in 6.8% of patients. The comparative data of analgetic effect in the use of different methods of treatment of non-resectable pancreas tumor cases are given in table 1.
Table 1. Analgetic effect in the use of different methods of treatment of non-resectable pancreas tumor cases
| Pain syndrome changes |
Treatment method |
| Cryosurgical |
Cryoradiation |
Cryosurgical
+c/t |
|
| Partial analgesia |
50% |
18,2% |
30% |
|
| Full analgesia |
33,3% |
72,8% |
70% |
|
As evident from the data presented in the Table 1, the combined treatment has the most pronounced analgesia: within the period of 2-3 months, a stable analgesia is observed in all patients subject to cryoradiation treatment, which is positively higher than in the case of cryosurgical treatment.
After the conducted treatment, the survival of patients with non-resectable locally propagated cystadenocarcinoma and endocrinocellular cancer of pancreas body and tail is much higher. Thus, after cryosurgical treatment of locally propagated endocrinocellular cancer of pancreas, the survival of one patient was 39 months. The survival of a patient with cystadenocarcinoma of pancreas body and tail was 30 months.
The group of 44 patients with non-resectable tumors of pancreas distal zones was discussed above. Further, we’ll proceed with the analysis of the group of 7 patients with the tumors of pancreas distal ones, wherein cryoapplication was combined with a radical operation. 4 patients with duct adenocarcinoma and one patient with cystadenocarcinoma of pancreas body and tail were subject to distal subtotal resection with further cryodestruction of the tumor bed. The patient with cystadenocarcinoma of pancreas body-tail was subject to radiation therapy in the postoperation period in the mode of dose superfractionation of SOD 40 + 23 g, followed by chemotherapy. She died in 123 months following the operation. One patient with duct adenocarcinoma was subject to circular resection of UMV (upper mesenteric vein) with its further plastics with synthetic prothesis. The patient died in 3 months following treatment. The rest of the duct adenocarcinoma cases lived out 12, 8, and 4 months. The median was 6.75 months.
The last two patients were subject to cryodestruction of the pancreas body and tail at the first stage of surgical intervention, followed by distal subtotal resection of celiac trunk and edge resection of upper mesenteric vein. In the postoperation period, the radiation therapy was prescribed to the patient, which at SOD 8 u was suspended through a general radiation reaction. The patient died in 7 months following the operation. The second patient was subject to chemotherapy in the postoperation period. In the process of treatment, dissemination - lung metastases - were revealed. The patient is alive in the course of 20 months.
Cryoapplication in case of pancreas head cancer
In view of the risk of duodenum necrosis, a cryosurgical method as an independent method may not be used in the patients with pancreas head cancer. However, we used cryodestruction in respect of resectable pancreas head tumor for prevention of dissemination at mechanical damage of tumor in the process of its mobilization. Thereafter, a standard resection of pancreas head tumor was performed.
Such scheme was applied in 2 patients. These patients had a moderately differentiated adenocarcinoma of pancreas head. Both patients were in the IV-th stage of the disease as a result of local tumor dissemination (invasion into duodenum wall, retroperitoneal invasion, upper mesenteric vein invasion of B type.). Following tumor cryodestruction, pancreatoduodenectomy was performed. At that, resection of vessels was performed in both cases: in the first case - circular resection of upper mesenteric vein, in the second case - resection of upper mesenteric vein/upper vein. The clinical observation of the first patient is given below:
Patient A, 65 years old, was in the Liver and Pancreas Surgery Ward of Russian Oncological Center of RAMS in April 2003 with the following diagnosis: pancreas head cancer, T4 N1 MO, IV A stage.
In January 2003, loose stools appeared, the patient went down by 12 kg. In the course of domiciliary examination, a bulk neoplasm of pancreas head was revealed. The patient was sent to the Russian Oncological Center of RAMS. In the course of ultrasound investigation (USI) MRT and angiography, a pancreas head tumor node was revealed, dimensions 3.1×2.7×2.5 cm, with increased parapancreatic lymph nodes. In needle cytobiopsy of the node, the cells of adenocarcinoma were revealed. No icterus was observed, C A-19-9 3169,0.
The patient was operated on 25.04.03. . The following was established: 3×4 cm tumor of pancreas head with a conglomerate of soft-consistency lymph nodes palpated in the mesentery root. No liver or abdominal metastases were revealed. No ascites was revealed. The gall bladder 7×4 cm was moderately strained. Gastropancreatoduodenectomy was performed with prior cryodestruction of pancreas head tumor and circular resection of upper mesenteric vein. Histological study of the resected complex: the tumor in the pancreas head had the structure of a moderately differentiated adenocarcinoma, with metastases in the back pancreatoduodenal lymph nodes being of the same structure. In 4 months following the operation, propagation of the process, with metastases to peritoneal lymph nodes, was revealed. Gemzar chemotherapy was prescribed, which was performed in the course of one year. Against this background, a regress of peritoneal lymph nodes was observed. Chemotherapy was suspended. The patient was under dynamic observation. In the course of control examination in May 2006, a metastasis to L5 vertebra was revealed. No other tumor changes were revealed. Chemoradiation therapy was prescribed. The patient is alive in the course of 37 months.
At present, practically all patients with pancreas head cancer are subject to adjuvant chemotherapy with the use of advanced medications (Gemzar) following radical surgical treatment in the scope of resection of pancreas head. However, far from all patients have such pronounced results following cryodestruction and conventionally radical operation as in the above-described case.
The second patient did not receive any additional treatment. His survival was 22 months.
Thus, pancreas tumor cryodestruction is relatively safe, efficient, controllable, and has a sufficient destructive affect. The advantages of this method are as follows: biological inertness of cryonecrosis nidus and simplicity of the method. It is also known for its clinical efficiency: analgetic effect and increase in lifetime. Cryodestruction of pancreas tumors may be combined with other methods of treatment.
Alongside with the aforementioned, the role and importance of the cryosurgical methods in treatment of patients with biliopancreatoduodenal zone tumors is still to be studied. The given examples of highly-efficient treatment of the pancreas duct cancer, including cryosurgical effect on tumors, were observed in single patients. It may be more the evidence of biological peculiarities of certain tumors and individual immunobiological characteristics of certain patients than of efficiency of the treatment as such. Besides, the observations of successful treatment of pancreas duct cancer were observed in the cases of using cryodestruction in combination with its surgical excision, and cryodestruction with further cytostatic chemotherapy. In connection with it, the following studies have been conducted in our clinic: study of prognostic role of a number of molecular-genetic factors in pancreas duct cancer patients, who were subject to cryosurgical treatment; study of the role of cryosurgical treatment in combination with surgical treatment and combined method of treatment of pancreas duct cancer patients etc. Following their completion, the clinical oncology will acquire the new knowledge indispensable in the practice of treatment of Pancreas Duct cancer patients.